Archive for category Historical Mystery

Review: THE LOVER by Laura Wilson

The Lover

Laura Wilson

Felony and Mayhem Press

ISBN: 978-1-934609-88-0

$14.95

321 pages

Reviewed by Amanda Capper

The Lover is a very good read with the added titillation of being a BOAT (Based on a True). This book revolves around The Blackout Ripper and will entice any fan of true crime to research further, if for no other reason than to see just how much in common The Lover has with Jack the Ripper.

Set in London during the Second World War, the story centers on three characters; Lucy, a young woman reaching maturity during uncertain times; Rene, a prostitute constantly living under a threat of local violence; and Jim, an Air Force pilot who becomes the love interest of Lucy. The author writes in the first person for each of these characters and does an excellent job of keeping the voice of each character distinct. Laura Wilson also does an excellent job of suspense, tying the characters together at crucial points of the story and giving the reader a very good idea of what motivates both victim and murderer.

The Lover also reminds us how darn good we have it these days. If our cable goes down, or our internet speed slows, we think we’re hard done by. But black-outs were routine during the war. In order to decrease targets for enemy planes, all lights were extinguished and Londoners were expected to head for air raid shelters under ground. Where they sat and listened to the bombs fall, wondering all the time if the bombs would fall on their homes and any loved ones who didn’t make it to an air raid shelter in time. Add to these fears the horror of someone attacking and mutilating the most helpless of women and you have an account of a whole city on the brink of insanity.

It is a can’t-put-down, up-all-night type of book because you want/need to know what happens next to these three main characters, as well as the secondary characters woven into their lives. As with any good book, when the end comes, you want more. Guaranteed to send the reader into research mode.

 

Copyright © 2011 Amanda Capper

DISCLOSURE OF MATERIAL CONNECTION: I have a material connection because I received a review copy that I can keep for consideration in preparing to write this content. I was not expected to return this item after my review.

 

No Comments

Review: A SPARK OF DEATH by Bernadette Pajer

A Spark Of Death

Bernadette Pajer

Poisoned Pen Press

ISBN: 978-1-59058-907-6

Reviewed by Ronald Smyth

When University of  Washington Professor Oglethorpe is discovered dead inside the Faraday Cage of the Electric Machine the police cry murder and Professor Bradshaw is the chief suspect, especially in the eyes of the public, thanks to some newspaper articles that imply he should be behind bars. But the killer wants him dead.

This is the first book in a proposed new Professor Bradshaw Mystery Series and the professor is a well drawn and sympathetic character who should be well able to sustain a series. His convincingly written and sympathetic backstory makes his reactions to the murder of a colleague and his attempts to maintain control of his world while it careens out of his ability to do so both believable and interesting, probably the most important part of any novel. The plot too is well set out and the science involved explained in comprehensible terms rather than jargon, such that a layman can grasp the ideas involved.

Nor is the Professor a mere armchair detective but a man of action as well, able to save himself from drowning when called upon for direct action. He’ll need both his brawn and brain when he decides that he must involve himself in a private investigation of the murder if he wishes to clear himself from suspicion and not have to reveal his greatest secret to his son.

After character and plot the next most important part of a book is the setting and here the book falters but only slightly. The time is early 1901 and the place is the bustling town of Seattle, a mixture of western frontier town and new century progress where electicity is as much feared as it is wanted. While not entirely lacking in local and historic touches and details, the sort of tidbit that makes a place come alive in a writers words, I think that a great deal more of the “War of the Currents”, as it was called, between Edison’s direct current and Westinghouse’s alternating could have made the era seem more real, given the importance of the early days of electical invention to this book. I also felt that social attitudes as expressed in this book were too modern to be believed. I remember talking to an elderly relative of mine, born in 1900, and her telling me how in her youth it was no worse to be a murderer than to be an adulterer. Sex outside marriage was strictly forbidden and I did not get anything like that attitude from this book.

Nevertheless, I will certainly be looking for the next Professor Bradshaw mystery.

Copyright 2011 Ronald Smyth

1 Comment

Review: DEATH AT PULLMAN by Frances McNamara

Death at Pullman

An Emily Cabot Mystery

Frances McNamara

Allium Press of Chicago 2011

Trade Paperback

ISBN 978-0-9840676-9-5 * $14.00

262 Pages

Reviewed by Diane Grace

In the vein of a Miss Marple a young Miss Cabot travels to a company town south of Chicago to do good deeds and finds deaths and mysteries. There is action in this book, it is no cerebral exercise from an armchair. There are star-crossed lovers, and danger from known and unknown violent people. Miss Cabot herself gets carried away, in her mind a servant of justice, until reality intrudes. There is joy and sorrow in plenty. The protagonist reads as a young woman of her time. The writer on the very last page promises more from Miss Cabot. And more will be most welcome.

Frances McNamara has studied the era carefully and readily inserts a reference here and there that would be missed by the casual writer. The book is based on the factual town created by Pullman for his workers. She writes well and captures and holds the reader’s interest throughout. Her writing skills are impressive and nowhere is there a jarring note.

If there is one thing I would wish is that the Prologue and Epilogue were dropped. They do not add to this book.

On the whole I recommend that you make room for this book in your library. I hope you enjoy it as much as I did.

DISCLOSURE OF MATERIAL CONNECTION: I have a material connection because I received a review copy that I can keep for consideration in preparing to write this content. I was not expected to return this item after my review.

, ,

No Comments

Review: Death at Hull House by Frances McNamara

Death at Hull House

An Emily Cabot Mystery

Frances McNamara

Allium Press of Chicago, December 2009 

ISBN: 978-0-9840676-0-2 

Trade paperback, 264 pages 

$14.99 

Reviewed by Sue Ann Connaughton
The year is 1893. Emily Cabot, one of the first students to attend the University of Chicago, has been expelled from the graduate school. To redeem herself, the reputation of the University, and the credibility of women as scholars, she is dispatched to work at Hull House, a settlement house in the impoverished, immigrant-dense West Side neighborhood of Chicago. The plan is for Emily to organize the data from an important Hull House survey of households and prepare it for publication.

During her residency at Hull House, Emily plunges into various community projects under the tutelage of two committed women: Jane Addams, the diplomatic founder of Hull House, and Mrs. Florence Kelley, a fearless, mysterious divorcée. By the time her brother Alden arrives in Chicago determined to find the man who murdered their father a few years earlier, Emily has begun to doubt that Hull House will ever accomplish any of its goals in the politically-stacked, profit-motivated West Side of Chicago. The world of academia recedes as Emily spends her days and nights chasing garbage carts, investigating the abuses of sweat shops, and attempting to contain a smallpox epidemic. On Christmas, she finds a murdered businessman in Hull House. Suspects and motives for the murders of the businessman and her father are rumored, discounted, and finally resolved. Along the way, Emily grows beyond her privileged background into a self-aware woman who makes difficult, but informed choices.

The second in a historical mystery series set in Chicago, Death at Hull House offers more than a mystery story populated by do-good feminists and shady politicians. It’s based on an actual settlement house in Chicago. The social and political environment ring true, as do the ills and economic problems of the community. This is a satisfying book to read, rich and delicious with details of a time, place, and people in transition.

Copyright 2010 Sue Ann Connaughton

DISCLOSURE OF MATERIAL CONNECTION
I have a material connection because I received a review copy that I can keep for consideration in preparing to write this content. I was not expected to return this item after my review.

No Comments

Review: A CURTAIN FALLS by Stefanie Pintoff

A Curtain Falls

Stefanie Pintoff

Minotaur Books, New York

ISBN 978-0-312-58396-5

Reviewed by Marlene Pyle

This mystery marks the return of Detective Simon Ziele, first introduced in the author’s debut novel, In the Shadow of Gotham.

Set in New York City in the early 1900’s, this crime story is just as appealing as its predecessor. Ziele is a compelling character with a well-developed background from the first novel, deepened in this one with further glimpses of his past. The supporting characters are richly drawn as well, and Ziele’s relationships with them have grown and changed from one novel to the next.

The story opens with a court case in which Ziele has brought to trial a woman accused of poisoning her husband. There is no doubt in Ziele’s mind that she is a murderer and he is bitterly disappointed when she manages to convince the jury of her innocence. Ziele knows well that things are not always what they seem. The author is a master at foreshadowing and creating suspense.

Our hero is called to investigate the murder of a Broadway chorus girl. She is the second actress to be found dead in the theater within a matter of days. The first was thought to be a suicide, but now it is clear that something more sinister is going on. Ziele fears that a serial killer is behind the deaths. A suspect is quickly brought into custody, but he insists he is innocent, and while no one else is convinced, Ziele’s gut instincts tell him they have the wrong man.

Once again, he teams up with eccentric criminologist Alistair Sinclair to find the criminal. The interaction between these two is always interesting. Their history reveals that while they respect each other’s intelligence, they don’t trust one another, and are wary of working together. Also involved is Sinclair’s beautiful widowed daughter-in-law, Isabella. Here too, Ziele is guarded, but their attraction is slowly building. New pieces of Ziele’s personal life are brought forth, providing more insight into his character and personality.

Pintoff has proved that she’s more than a one-hit wonder with this novel. Readers will eagerly anticipate the next tale of Deterctive Ziele.

Copyright 2010  Marlene Pyle

*I have a material connection because I received a review copy that I can keep for consideration in preparing to write this content. I was not expected to return this item after my review.

No Comments

Review: IN THE SHADOW OF GOTHAM by Stefanie Pintoff

 

ISBN 978-0-312-54490-4In the Shadow of Gotham
Hardcover, 400 pages
Minotaur

Reviewed by Marlene Pyle

 

In the Shadow of Gotham is an historical crime novel, set in New York in the early 1900’s.  A young woman is murdered in her own home, and Detective Simon Ziele is sent to investigate.  He is working with a criminologist from Columbia University and together the two must unravel the strange circumstances of this killing.  

 

Police procedures, of course, were vastly different 100 years ago.  It was fascinating to read about the early stages of fingerprinting techniques and the beginnings of what we know today as “criminal profiling.”  Ms. Pintoff, herself a graduate of Columbia Law School, has done an excellent job of researching these areas and her richly-detailed plot makes for a smoothly flowing novel.  

 

As a winner of the Minotaur Books/Mystery Writer’s of America First Crime Novel Competition, In the Shadow of Gotham will be a tough act to follow for future entrants.  

 

Copyright © 2009   Marlene Pyle

No Comments